The Market Ticker
Commentary on The Capital Markets

I was wondering when law enforcement was going to start doing its damn job.

A legal storm is building after a D.C. judge ordered a web hosting company to give the government a broad swath of data about individuals connected to an anti-Trump website despite arguments that doing so would impinge on their First Amendment rights and stifle online political discourse.

At a hearing Thursday morning in D.C. Superior Court, Chief Judge Robert E. Morin insisted he would put restrictions on how the government reviews the material in order to protect those rights. The government must disclose to the court who will search the material and what process they will use. They must also develop a plan to minimize the search of material unrelated to criminal activity.

You have a First Amendment right to speak.

You do not have a First Amendment right to riot, engage in vandalism or otherwise conduct criminal activity and coordinating, bragging, or announcing intent to do so on the Internet is direct and admissible evidence of intent and thus not only can be used to evidence guilt in an instant case it can also be used to support a charge of conspiracy, mob action, racketeering or similar crimes which involve the coordination of actions by multiple people.

When I ran MCSNet we quite routinely got subpoenaed for various information; there was not one instance in which I considered the subpoena to be worthy of fighting.  That's not to say there couldn't have been one during that time, just that it never happened in my experience.

This particular issue, in my opinion, falls into the "give it to them" category.  It's clear that the people in question coordinated and communicated using this system and then went on to commit criminal activity; there are 200-odd said people who are currently charged and in the dock. 

As such this is not a fishing expedition (which I would oppose); it's aimed directly at the prosecution of said people.

So yeah, folks, if you're going to do illegal things it's a bad idea to do it online where there is virtually always a record kept.  In fact on the blog here said records are kept for routine business and operational reasons (e.g. interdicting spam, etc) and if subpoenaed such a demand certainly looks both reasonable and lawful to me.

What I find even more-amusing are the claims that encrypted communications or acts (e.g. Bitcoin) make one secure.  The exact opposite is in fact true; an encrypted communication is by definition admissible evidence because it is mathematically impossible for it to be emitted by anyone other than the keyholder; ergo, unless your key is stolen the fact that such a transmission exists and verifies against your public key means you sent it, period.  When it comes to things like Bitcoin it's even more-amusing because the conclusive, admissible evidence is intentionally published to the world on an irrevocable basis and thus it is absolutely able to be tied to whoever holds that private key half forever into the future.  If whatever that transaction evidences is illegal and that key have can be tied to you at any point in the future you're done.

The contents of an encrypted conversation may well be secret but who emitted it and that it has not been altered is knowable as an absolute, mathematically-provable fact.

You're not anonymous on the Internet, especially when you use encrypted protocols.



View this entry with comments (opens new window)

Sarah has three canvas pieces and two planet pieces left; the rest are spoken for.

Come and get 'em before they're gone!

One of the remaining pieces...

 by tickerguy

See 'em here:

View this entry with comments (opens new window)

2017-09-19 07:00 by Karl Denninger
in Editorial , 178 references
[Comments enabled]  

What do you get when you reduce diversity of generation of electricity, take offline nuclear plants, demand that nobody use coal any more, and otherwise restrict where power comes from so you have fewer and less-diverse sources of energy?

You get crap when a hurricane shows up, that's what.

Many of those powerless residents are now asking hard questions of the area's power monopoly, which has spent millions of dollars fighting policies that would have strengthened the grid in the event of a major storm like Irma and, more broadly, stemmed the carbon-fueled climate change likely fueling monster storms.

"I am one of the many that has now been without power for more than two days as a result of Hurricane Irma," Elise McKenna, a West Palm Beach resident, told New Times via email. "My confusion came when so many of us lost power during the early hours of the storm that basically avoided us. We've been told time and time again that rate increases were to help prepare us for future storms."


Look, there are plenty of reasons to rag on FPL.  One of them is their insane (and heavily-lobbied for) requirements for connections to the grid for alternative energy sources.  But attempting to blame heavily-lobbied-for requirements on solar installs for the current outages is stupid -- first, there are next to zero solar installs on a home that can start and run an air conditioner, so in this particular instance you'd still have your sweltering heat.  Remember, it's not the running amps that matter it's starting amps and there is no buffer on a solar panel array that comes from the "sag" that a rotating generator has.  This works to your advantage when starting a motor load such as a compressor; a 5 ton AC unit can be successfully started on a ~14-15kva genset -- usually.  No such luck with solar; you need to be able to source the entire lock-rotor rating on the motor for a short period of time without tripping the inverter connected to the panels.  This could be as much as 140 amps, which means you need somewhere on the order of 30kva of solar panels with nothing else running to start that unit.

Now there are "cheats" available, including true PWM-modulated start units.  They cost a few hundred bucks.  Do you have one in your condenser?  The time to figure it out isn't after the hurricane comes, by the way, and they're not standard in any off-the-shelf household units.  Guess how many of those units are likely found around Florida's home A/C units?  What is zero, Alex?

Now let's say you put one of these in.  You're good, right?  Yes, right up until a cloud shades part of your panel array and the output drops below the running amps of the unit momentarily.  Oops.  There's another trip and again with no buffering from the grid off goes the air!

Can you build a fully-independent, buffered power system?  Sure.  How much money do you have?  There are damn few if not zero of those laying around in residential installations simply because they make no economic sense even with tax subsidies if you can connect to the grid.

So yeah, spare me the whines about solar and how FPL "screwed" you, because the typical larger residential solar system delivers something like one quarter what it takes to start that AC unit.  Maybe.

The real issue here is twofold, with the largest issue being a major reduction in the diversity of generation sources.  This hurts bigtime when bad things happen to the grid, because you can have all the power generation capability you wish but if you can't deliver it to customers it's worthless.  In addition concentrating generation sources mean that when one larger system gets taken down due to severe weather it impacts more people since there are fewer, larger generation sources rather than more, smaller ones.  The more screaming you do about Globull BULL**** the more you make this problem worse.

The one place FPL could have done more and better is underground transmission.  But that's not a panacea.  Underground vaults can flood and if they do they can short out the lines, which is just as bad as having them blown over and can be worse if they're energized at the time.  Never mind that it's a hell of a lot harder (takes longer) to fix an underground vault and put it back in service than it is an above-ground transformer!  Not only is it more expensive to run wires underground it requires more and thicker wire too because the heat dissipation capacity of said wire is less.  Combined with less diversity of generation sources you wind up with more "pockets" of material size where restoration takes longer.

If you live somewhere subject to severe weather you need to think about these things in advance.  Yes, it sucks with no A/C in Florida.  Been there done that.  But reality is that it is we, the people who have permitted the scam known as "Globull Warming" to take root, it is we the people who have made demands and then we get upset when the consequences come.

Either cut the crap or buy a generator large enough to start your A/C -- and if you do the latter then marvel at exactly how cheap your power from the utility company really is when you have to feed that biatch with gasoline or diesel.  You'll gain a lot of respect for the power company the first time you actually run one of these things for a while and total up the gas bill along with the required maintenance such as oil changes and the like -- which, when on 24x7, are required every couple of days!

View this entry with comments (opens new window)

2017-09-18 08:09 by Karl Denninger
in Musings , 109 references
[Comments enabled]  

No, not my art, and yes, I'm biased.  I think it's all extraordinary work....

Sarah's art.  She's selling some (nowhere near all) of her recent work, and you're invited to check it out and let her know what you'd like!

Please do drop over to her blog's post and check it out!

Thanks in advance!

View this entry with comments (opens new window)

For a firm to place someone, who happens to be a woman, with a Masters in Music in charge of their corporate data security is not only either an obvious diversity hire or one of the most-obnoxious acts of nepotism or otherwise "paying it backward" of all time.

For that to have happened within a company that holds personal data on damn near every single American adult is outright criminal.

That the company appears to have tried to whitewash or even cover it up is even worse.

This calls for not just prison for the executives involved but the corporate death penalty for the company.

Folks, either we all stand in unison and demand that this firm be put out of business now and forevermore, and that for the indefinite future you are able to freeze and unfreeze your credit file without cost, at any time and for any reason or we as a nation deserve to be nuked to ash by the Korean Rocketman.

View this entry with comments (opens new window)

Main Navigation
MUST-READ Selection:
A One-Sentence Bill To Force The Health-Care Issue

Full-Text Search & Archives
Archive Access
Legal Disclaimer

The content on this site is provided without any warranty, express or implied. All opinions expressed on this site are those of the author and may contain errors or omissions.


The author may have a position in any company or security mentioned herein. Actions you undertake as a consequence of any analysis, opinion or advertisement on this site are your sole responsibility.

Market charts, when present, used with permission of TD Ameritrade/ThinkOrSwim Inc. Neither TD Ameritrade or ThinkOrSwim have reviewed, approved or disapproved any content herein.

The Market Ticker content may be sent unmodified to lawmakers via print or electronic means or excerpted online for non-commercial purposes provided full attribution is given and the original article source is linked to. Please contact Karl Denninger for reprint permission in other media, to republish full articles, or for any commercial use (which includes any site where advertising is displayed.)

Submissions or tips on matters of economic or political interest may be sent "over the transom" to The Editor at any time. To be considered for publication your submission must include full and correct contact information and be related to an economic or political matter of the day. All submissions become the property of The Market Ticker.